By Fr. Gregory Pine, O.P.
Knowing how to talk about politics as a Catholic can sometimes feel draining and dehumanizing. We might feel like we’re losing touch with who we are.
When we think about politics, it’s easy to feel discouraged or frustrated. It can seem like no one’s telling the truth or that nothing will change.
My name is Father Gregory Pine. I teach at the Dominican House of Studies in Washington, D.C., and work as an assistant director at the Thomistic Institute. Today, I want to offer you a bit of encouragement for engaging with politics.
It seems like the quality of political conversations has declined over the years. People tend to either glorify their candidate and demonize the opposition. And then there’s those of us who prefer to avoid these discussions because they seem messy. Read on to find out why it’s still important, and get some tips on how to talk about politics as a Catholic.
1. Be Willing to Engage in Politics
The first step in learning how to talk about politics as a Catholic? Be open and willing.
We, as human beings, only come to fulfillment in community. God made us to be social, and even political, beings. Politics doesn’t have to be dirty—we can do it virtuously, without losing ourselves in shouting matches.
Engaging in local communities, promoting the common good—whether in your family, neighborhood, or nation—is part of who we are.
Some people may tell you, “Just vote, that’s it.” While voting is important, it’s not the whole picture. The bigger part is being willing to have conversations, especially with friends or people you disagree with.
If you retreat from disagreement, it might be time to engage more, even if it feels uncomfortable. Disagreements don’t have to lead to anger or broken relationships. In fact, they can help you grow in mutual respect and love. On top of that, you may be making points or informing about Catholic teaching that maybe the person you are engaging with has not heard before. These conversations can end up being life-changing at best, and informative at worst. So, there’s really no con when you engage with an open heart guided by the Holy Spirit.
2. Contribute Where You Can
Many of us look at politics and feel powerless. We see big problems we can’t control, and it can lead to feelings of despair. But there are ways to make a difference. Maybe that means getting involved in student government, local charities, or even the neighborhood rec league. It’s not just about getting involved for the sake of it—it’s about caring for the things around us so that they improve. A common critique in politics is that people often claim to support certain rights or causes but fail to take tangible steps to promote them. By getting involved, you’re not only reinforcing your beliefs through action but also gaining valuable education and personal growth in the process.
Now that you know how to talk about politics as a Catholic, learn How To Talk To People About Jesus.
3. Don’t Let Anyone Take Away Your Humanity
Sometimes in heated political debates, we find ourselves saying or doing things we later regret.
Hold on to your humanity by recognizing that there are good things out there that can make us better people. Avoid media or conversations that are only designed to stir up emotions, but don’t withdraw completely from the important discussions that need to happen.
Remember to always let the Holy Spirit guide you. If you enter into a discussion asking the Holy Spirit to lead you, rest assured that God has got you. You, the people you engage with, the political nominees, and everyone else share one simple thing in common. We are all human, we are all loved by our Father, and we are all equal. It’s our job to help each other become the holiest versions of ourselves!
Even if our political community seems like it’s in a tailspin, you have what you need to flourish as a human being. You have your family, your nation, and your church. God never gives us trials we can’t handle. He wants to bring us together in bonds that help us go to Him as a community, because ultimately, we reach God together.
As Aristotle said, “The man who lives alone is either a beast or a god.” We are neither—we’re human beings, meant for relationships, even when they’re hard.
FAQ: Tips for Navigating Political Conversations and Engagement
1. Why are political conversations so challenging?
Political discussions can feel exhausting and dehumanizing because they often devolve into shouting matches, demonization, or oversimplified arguments. This makes it tempting to disengage entirely, but it’s important to remain involved in meaningful ways.
2. What does it mean to engage politically as a Catholic?
Engaging politically means contributing to the common good of your family, community, nation, and Church. It involves participating in conversations, voting, and working on local initiatives while maintaining a sense of humanity and virtue.
3. How can I navigate political disagreements?
Start by being willing to engage in conversations, even when disagreements arise. Focus on mutual respect and avoid retreating due to discomfort. Be steadfast, but not condescending. Aim to educate and inform, but in a generous way. Healthy back-and-forth discussions can foster growth and deeper understanding without becoming hostile.
4. What are practical ways to contribute politically?
You can contribute by getting involved in your local community, such as joining the Parent-Teacher Organization (PTO), volunteering for local boards, or participating in neighborhood projects. By getting involved, you’re not only reinforcing your beliefs through action but also gaining valuable education and personal growth in the process.
5. How can I avoid losing my humanity during political engagement?
Stay grounded in truth and avoid reacting purely out of opposition to those you disagree with. Seek meaningful conversations and projects that contribute to the common good. A good tip: Avoid sources designed to provoke anger or division – get your information and make sure it is accurate, but try to discern to the best of your ability. In other words, before you send or even read an article, say a quick prayer for prudence and wisdom.
6. Is voting enough for a Catholic?
Voting is important, but it’s just one aspect of political engagement. True change happens through sustained involvement in local and broader community efforts, fostering dialogue, and working toward the common good.
7. What should I do if I feel overwhelmed by the state of politics?
Focus on what you can control and where you can make a difference. Avoid despair by remembering that meaningful change begins in your family, community, and Church. God calls us to participate in society as social and political beings.
8. How does political engagement connect to faith?
Political engagement is part of living out your vocation as a social and ecclesial being. As Catholics, we are here to advance justice and the common good, reflecting God’s love in our interactions and decisions.
9. What should I avoid in political conversations?
Avoid unproductive outlets or conversations that are designed to provoke anger or fear. Instead, seek out spaces where meaningful and respectful dialogue can occur, even when topics are challenging.
10. Where can I learn more about voting as a Catholic?
For guidance on voting as a Catholic, consider reaching out to your parish for materials or resources. You can also visit your diocese’s website or explore resources provided by the USCCB (United States Conference of Catholic Bishops) for insights on how to align your vote with Catholic teachings.
Additional Resources
For even more great Catholic resources, check out our podcast, which features talks from our SEEK conference, and our YouTube channel for videos and more!
Give
